Did you know that the nickel was not America’s first five-cent coin, and that there is a nickel worth $4,408,650?
The nickel has been through many changes since its creation in the 1790s, both in design and material.
During the Civil War, fearful of financial crisis or governmental collapse, many Americans stockpiled silver and gold coins. These hoarded coins were actually more valuable than paper money because the value of the metals used to make the coins was more than the nominal value engraved on the coin.
As coins vanished and gold and silver resources diminished, the U.S. Mint could not produce the nation’s coins. The United States turned its attention to a different type of metal — nickel.
In May of 1866, a new coin emerged composed of nickel and copper later to be known as “nickel”. After years of coin shortages, nickels flooded the economy. The government minted 15 million five-cent nickels, drastically exceeding its counterpart, the silver half-dime, of which fewer than 200,000 were produced the prior year.
The nickel was the coin of choice for a long time, even with the dime and quarter being of greater value. This is greatly due to the rise of coin-operated machines such as vending machines and jukeboxes. There were also nickel theaters and, for 73 years, a bottle of Coca-Cola was only five cents.
The story of the nickel has come full-circle. Once considered “cheap metal,” nickel and copper have increased in value over the past one hundred and fifty years. The U.S. Government Accountability Office reports that it costs eight cents to produce every five-cent piece. Thinking about melting your nickels? Don’t. The act has been illegal since 2006.
Here is a list of the top five most valuable nickels minted in the United States since the late 1800’s.
1913 Liberty Head V Nickel
Worth $4,408,650, just five of these coins are known to exist. These coins are extremely rare, as just five are known to exist.
1880 Shield Nickel
Just 16,000 of these coins were produced. One mint state coin was recently sold at auction for $20,000.
1924 S Buffalo Nickel
Worth $14,000 in mint state condition, 1,437,000 of these coins were produced. If not in mint state, one 1924 buffalo nickel is still worth about $17.
1926 S Buffalo Nickel
The 1926 buffalo nickel is also worth about $17. About 970,000 of these coins were produced, and a mint state nickel could be worth $7,600.
1927 S Buffalo Nickel
The 1927 buffalo nickel is also only worth about $2, but if in mint state, it can fetch as much as $5,000. About 3,430,000 of these coins were produced.
Sources: Coin Trackers | History | Smithsonian Magazine | Money